How can we help? +44 (0)1704 543830 | info@isotech.co.uk

Beyond Resolution: Understanding Accuracy in Dry Block Temperature Calibration

Dry block calibrators are vital tools in temperature calibration, offering convenient and fast calibration of sensors. However, when evaluating performance, users often place undue emphasis on display resolution. This article explores the limitations of resolution as a performance indicator, identifies the key contributors to uncertainty, and uses a practical example to show how little resolution influences the result when properly evaluated.

Dry Block Calibration

Resolution vs Accuracy: A Fundamental Distinction

It is essential to differentiate between resolution and accuracy when evaluating a calibrator:

  • Resolution: Resolution is the smallest temperature increment displayed by a calibrator. It is a digital feature, and by itself, does not improve measurement performance.
  • Accuracy: Accuracy refers to how close a measured or indicated value is to the true temperature, typically verified using a calibrated reference thermometer.

While higher resolution may improve readability, it often has minimal impact on overall calibration uncertainty, as other sources — such as thermal gradients and probe loading — typically contribute far more significantly.

What Really Affects Calibration Quality

Dry Block Resolution and Accuracy

According to internationally recognised guidance documents such as EURAMET cg-13 and ASTM E3186-19, the following factors typically dominate the uncertainty budget in dry block calibration:

  • Stability: The ability of the calibrator to maintain a setpoint over time.
  • Axial and Radial Uniformity: Differences in temperature within the calibration block.
  • Loading Effects: Influence of inserting probes into the well.
  • Immersion Depth and Insert Fit: Poor contact or inadequate depth causes errors.
  • Calibration Method: Comparison with a high-accuracy reference thermometer.

These are thermal and practical factors that significantly impact real-world performance and compliance with ISO/IEC 17025.

Considering the Impact of Resolution

To demonstrate the limited influence of display resolution, consider a simplified uncertainty budget for a dry block calibrator at 100 °C. All uncertainty sources are treated as independent and follow a rectangular (uniform) distribution. Two scenarios are compared:

  • Scenario A: Resolution = 0.01 °C
  • Scenario B: Resolution = 0.001 °C

When a digital instrument shows values with fixed resolution, the actual temperature could fall anywhere within the smallest displayed step. Because we can’t know its exact position within that interval, it’s standard practice to assume the error is evenly spread across it—so we use half the least significant digit (LSD) as the uncertainty contribution.

Note: Uncertainty from the reference thermometer is not included.

Source of UncertaintyValue ±DistributionDivisorciStandard Uncertainty (ui)
Radial non-uniformity0.010Rectangular1.7310.0058
Axial non-uniformity0.100Rectangular1.7310.0578
Loading effects0.050Rectangular1.7310.0289
Stability0.030Rectangular1.7310.0173
Display resolution (A)0.005Rectangular1.7310.0029
Display resolution (B)0.0005Rectangular1.7310.0003

Combined Uncertainty Results

  • Scenario A (Resolution = 0.01 °C):


    Combined Standard Uncertainty (uc): ≈ 0.0672 °C
    Expanded Uncertainty (k = 2): ±0.1344 °C
  • Scenario B (Resolution = 0.001 °C):


    Combined Standard Uncertainty (uc): ≈ 0.0672 °C
    Expanded Uncertainty (k = 2): ±0.1344 °C
Display ResolutionStandard Uncertainty (°C)Expanded Uncertainty (°C)
0.01 °C0.0672±0.1344
0.001 °C0.0672±0.1344

Therefore, the difference in expanded uncertainty (k = 2) between using a display resolution of 0.01 °C and 0.001 °C is negligible—effectively buried within numerical resolution and rounding, with no practical impact on calibration outcomes.

Conclusion

While display resolution is a highly visible specification and may improve readability, it is a minor contributor to the actual performance of a dry block calibrator. As demonstrated in the comparative example, gains from higher resolution are dominated by thermal effects such as axial gradients and probe loading.

Successful calibration depends not on the smallest displayed increment, but on:

  • Proper thermal design
  • High-quality reference standards
  • Rigorous calibration procedures
  • Well-characterised uncertainty budgets

For compliance with standards such as ISO/IEC 17025, calibration systems must be evaluated based on total measurement uncertainty — not marketing-driven resolution claims.

Explore our products

786 Low Rugged Dry Block Calibrator

786 Low Rugged Dry Block Calibrator

-40°C to +140°C

Product Spec
Venus 4951

Venus 4951

-35°C to 140°C

Product Spec
Fast-Cal Low

Fast-Cal Low

-35°C to 140°C

Product Spec
Quick Cal High

Quick Cal High

35°C to 350°C

Product Spec

Get In Touch

  • We value your privacy and will only use your details for this enquiry - which would normally include passing your details to a distributor in your area. See our Privacy Policy for further information.

  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
youtube linkedin
Isotech
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.